Existing strategy
Replay the documented frozen strategy without an additional quality gate.
We tested whether additional entry-quality checks could change paper-replay outcomes. The recorded comparison improved one partial session, but it did not produce a profitable result or justify changing production strategy rules.
Repository-documented comparison. Arithmetic independently checked; original market recording and replay were not rerun for publication.
Instead of changing stop-loss rules after a loss, the experiment inspected whether completed candle information available at decision time could improve entry selection.
Replay the documented frozen strategy without an additional quality gate.
Reject a directional candidate when completed 1-minute data shows adverse EMA5/MACD momentum or a two-candle exhaustion pattern.
Require the latest completed 5-minute candle direction and its close relative to EMA21 to agree with the candidate.
All three variants were evaluated over the same recorded October 16 window. These values come from the internal experiment report, not audited live-account brokerage statements.
| Variant | Closed trades | Win rate | Gross P&L | Net P&L after costs | Profit factor |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Existing baseline | 2 | 0% | −₹1,240.50 | −₹1,459.77 | 0.00 |
| Immediate 1-minute quality | 2 | 50% | −₹273.00 | −₹491.05 | 0.51 |
| Completed 5-minute alignment | 2 | 0% | −₹1,240.50 | −₹1,459.77 | 0.00 |
Improvement in net P&L from baseline to the immediate 1-minute variant. The outcome remained negative ₹491.05. The difference is a path-dependent replay comparison, not a forecast.
Different entries can change future cooldowns, open-position state, capital sizing and drawdown restrictions. Simply deleting losing trades from history would not recreate this counterfactual.
For October 16, the report identifies rejected replay candidates at 09:33, 09:58 and 10:56 under the immediate 1-minute gate.
The altered sequence subsequently produced different entries at 09:46 and 11:07 due to the evolving session state.
The completed 5-minute gate still allowed the early losing positions; its reported after-cost outcome matched the baseline in this window.
The report's limitations are as important as its numerical result. These findings are exploratory, not a release recommendation.
Two partial sessions were usable in the cross-session investigation, with just two closed trades per October 16 variant. This cannot establish a robust expectancy estimate.
The report says October 16 paper and replay outcomes were not identical. The controlled comparison supports hypothesis exploration, not a certified trade-by-trade reconstruction.
Replay trade setups were labeled UNKNOWN, preventing credible setup-level attribution from those rows.
Local fee estimates did not fully match broker estimates. The same cost model was used across variants, but absolute net P&L retains uncertainty.
We distinguish review of a source report and code from independently reproducing historical execution against the original private recording.
Reviewed the internal reports/research/immediate_1m_gate/FINDINGS.md study, including cohort scope, all three result rows, exclusions and limitations.
Baseline implied costs: ₹219.27. Immediate-filter implied costs: ₹218.05. Net difference: +₹968.72. Both remain negative.
Replayed data handling, session manifest validation, virtual clock, fill simulator tests and research workflows exist in the private Python codebase.
The private October 16 raw recording was not processed afresh for this public case study. Numerical outputs remain attributed to the repository research report.
Additional complete sessions, fresh fee reconciliation, paper/replay parity and an out-of-sample cohort are needed before strategy promotion.
The internal report explicitly recommended leaving strategy-v2026.10.15 unchanged, collecting a larger paper-session cohort and monitoring the immediate 1-minute quality check in shadow mode. A better result across two trades is not evidence of repeatable profitability.